Charisma Does Not Make You a Good Advisor


Photo by Chris Yang on Unsplash

Advisor Perspectives welcomes guest contributions. The views presented here do not necessarily represent those of Advisor Perspectives.

Click here to watch a video and learn more about Evidence Based Advisor Marketing

An article in The New York Times guided those who wish to be perceived as charismatic. It’s an interesting subject, but the goal is wrong-headed. Here’s why.

What is charisma?

The article quotes John Antonakis, a professor of organizational behavior at the University of Lausanne in Switzerland. He defines charisma as, “signaling information in a symbolic, emotional and value-based manner. Thus, charisma signaling is all about using verbalwhat you sayand nonverbal techniques.”

I don’t know what that means. It suggests making yourself appealing to others, commanding attention and having a magical presence in a room.

Flawed assumption

The premise of this article, and many others on the same subject, is that being charismatic (often expressed as the ability to “command a room, draw others to you, and convince people of your ideas”) is an advantageous personal trait. We’re told charismatic people, “are perceived as both likeable and powerful, a dynamic, irresistible combination that opens endless doors to them.”

For many – especially introverts like me – achieving this status would be a nightmare. The last thing I want to do is draw anyone to me and be the focus of their attention. I can already feel my palms sweating as I envision hordes of strangers approaching me because of some verbal or non-verbal signal I’ve inadvertently presented.

If you’re an introvert, you can relate. If you’re an extrovert, you may already believe you’re charismatic and wish to hone those skills.